Trump Praises Mexico For Effectively Closing The Border After Call With Sheinbaum, Who Disagrees

November 29, 2024 by Krishna Patel

Table of Contents

President-elect Donald Trump said he won a battle against illegal immigration after talking to Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum. He claimed on Truth Social that Sheinbaum agreed to stop migration through Mexico into the United States. This, he said, effectively closed the southern border.

However, Sheinbaum’s response was different. She said Mexico’s goal is to build bridges, not close borders. Both leaders said the call was positive, talking about immigration and illegal drugs. But they had very different views on what was agreed upon.

Key Takeaways

Trump falsely claimed Mexico agreed to stop migration and close the southern border.
Mexican President Sheinbaum clarified that Mexico’s position is to build bridges, not close borders.
Both leaders had differing interpretations of the call’s outcomes regarding immigration policies.
Social media users mocked Trump’s assertions, highlighting the discrepancy between his claims and Mexico’s actual stance.
The call highlighted ongoing tensions between the U.S. and Mexico over border control and immigration issues.

Trump’s Claims About Border Agreement with Mexico

Former US President Donald Trump recently said he made a “wonderful” deal with Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum. He claimed they agreed to close the southern border and stop migration into the US. But, President Sheinbaum quickly denied this, saying Mexico won’t close its borders.

Truth Social Announcement Details

Trump said on Truth Social that Mexico agreed to stop illegal immigration. He called it a big win for border security and US-Mexico relations. This was part of his efforts to control migration.

Border Closure Statement Analysis

President Sheinbaum said Mexico has no plans to close its borders. She stressed the importance of building bridges, not walls, between countries.

Implications for Immigration Policy

The disagreement between Trump and Sheinbaum makes it hard to predict immigration policy changes. Trump’s past claims about Mexico’s cooperation on border issues add to the confusion. It’s hard to know what will really happen.

Statistic	Value
Tariff announced by Trump on Mexico and Canada	25% across-the-board tariff
Tariff announced by Trump on China	10% tariff
Border crossings reduction under Biden administration	75% reduction over the past year
Border wall construction under Trump administration	458 miles, including 373 miles of the wall

The Trump administration focused a lot on border security and migration control. Trump often made claims about agreements with Mexico. But, the disagreement with President Sheinbaum shows how complex and uncertain immigration policy can be.

President Sheinbaum’s Contrasting Response to Border Discussion

As tensions rose between the U.S. and Mexico over border issues, President Claudia Sheinbaum took a different stance than Donald Trump. Trump said Sheinbaum agreed to close the Southern Border to stop migration. But Sheinbaum denied this claim.

Sheinbaum said Mexico wants to connect governments and communities, not close borders. She talked about solving migration’s root causes like poverty and lack of jobs. She mentioned working on solutions before migrants reach the border, but not stopping migration altogether.

Sheinbaum called her talk with Trump “good” and said she’s ready for more talks. She showed her dedication to Mexican foreign policy and diplomatic relations. Her approach is different from Trump’s, showing two ways to handle cross-border migration.

“Mexico’s position is not to close borders, but to build bridges between governments and communities,” said President Sheinbaum, emphasizing the need for cooperative solutions to address the root causes of migration.

Sheinbaum’s words highlight the value of diplomatic relations and a thoughtful approach to border management. This is in contrast to Trump’s claim of a broad border closure deal. The differing views of these leaders will influence the future of Mexican-US relations on this key issue.

Trade Tensions and Tariff Threats Between US and Mexico

The US-Mexico trade war is getting worse, with threats of tariffs. Former President Trump wanted a 25% tariff on all US imports from Mexico. He hoped this would push Mexico to act on immigration and drug trafficking.

These tariffs could hurt both countries a lot. They are each other’s biggest trading partners. Any trouble in their trade could cause big economic problems. Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum said Mexico would hit back with its own tariffs. This could risk jobs and businesses in both countries.

Proposed 25% Tariff Impact

Trump’s 25% tariff on Mexican imports could bring in about $266 billion in taxes. This would affect many industries. For instance, avocado farmers in Mexico worry that prices could go up by 25% in the US.

Economic Implications for Both Nations

These tariffs could lead to higher prices and slower growth. They might also harm the USMCA deal from 2020. US car makers like GM could see big problems, as their supply chains are all over North America.

Mexico’s Counter-Response to Tariffs

Mexico plans to fight back with its own tariffs on some US goods. This could make the trade war even worse. It could also hurt the long-standing trade ties between the two countries.

The US-Mexico trade war is still going on, and its effects are unclear. Finding a way through these trade issues is key to keeping the bilateral trade relations stable and growing.

Also Read: Dangerous Territory As Trump Unsecured Calls With World Leaders Concern Foreign Policy Experts

Historical Context of Trump-Mexico Border Relations

The current tensions between the United States and Mexico over border security and immigration policies have deep roots. During his 2016 campaign, Donald Trump vowed to build a wall along the US-Mexico border. He said Mexico would pay for it, a claim Mexico’s then-President Enrique Peña Nieto strongly opposed.

Since then, Mexico has continued to reject Trump’s unilateral demands. Trump’s push for stricter border control has led to many diplomatic disputes. These disagreements show how complex and contentious US-Mexico relations have become, especially under Trump.

Despite efforts to work together, like the Bracero Program, finding common ground has been hard. This program showed the economic benefits of smart immigration policies. Yet, the US and Mexico still struggle to agree on these critical issues. Their differing views and priorities highlight the need for a more cooperative approach to border management and immigration.

FAQs

Q: What did Trump say about Mexico’s border policies?

A: Trump praised Mexico for effectively closing the border during a call with Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum, highlighting the cooperation between the two countries.

Q: How did Claudia Sheinbaum respond to Trump’s comments?

A: Claudia Sheinbaum disagreed with Trump’s assessment, indicating that while cooperation is important, Mexico’s border policies are determined by its own national interests.

Q: What is the significance of Sheinbaum’s role as the first female president of Mexico?

A: Claudia Sheinbaum’s presidency marks a historic milestone for Mexico, as she is the first female president, highlighting a shift in gender representation in the country’s leadership.

Q: How might this interaction affect Trump’s campaign?

A: Trump’s praise for Mexico can be seen as an attempt to bolster his campaign narrative by showcasing foreign policy achievements that resonate with his voter base.

Q: What background does Claudia Sheinbaum have that influences her presidency?

A: Claudia Sheinbaum has a background in science and politics, previously serving as the mayor of Mexico City and aligning with the progressive policies of her predecessor, Andrés Manuel López Obrador.

Q: What policies could be affected by this discussion between Trump and Sheinbaum?

A: The discussion may influence policies related to immigration, tariffs, and foreign relations, as both leaders navigate their respective political agendas.

Q: How does the Mexican government view Trump’s presidency?

A: The Mexican government has had a complex relationship with Trump’s presidency, with officials often navigating challenges posed by his administration’s policies while seeking cooperation on issues like trade and security.

Q: What role does the National Guard play in Mexico’s border security?

A: The National Guard is deployed in Mexico to help combat cartel violence and enhance security at the borders, a key focus for the Sheinbaum administration in addressing public safety concerns.

Q: What impact could this call have on the upcoming election in Mexico?

A: The call could influence voter sentiment regarding Sheinbaum’s foreign policy stance, particularly if voters perceive her as effectively managing relations with the U.S. amid ongoing challenges.

Q: How do social programs factor into Sheinbaum’s administration?

A: Social programs are a priority for Sheinbaum’s administration, aiming to address poverty and inequality, which are often exacerbated by violence and economic instability in the country.

Source Links